RECENT
15 HeroClix Sets We Want
Top 12 Joker HeroClix
Top 5 DOFP HeroClix
Top 12 Spider-Man HeroClix
Top 10 Wildcards
15 Things You Don't Know About HeroClix
5 Fixes for Spiral
Top 5 Reasons Ben Affleck Will Suck as Batman

OTHER
Top 5 X-Men
Top 10 Worst Mutant Names
Top 5 Modern Age Supermans
Top 10 Iron Man Covers
Top 5 Modern Age Hulks
Top 10 Amazing Spider-Man Covers
Top 10 Aquarium HeroClix
10 Best Movie Hero Costumes
Top 20 in 2012
arrowTop 5 Hero vs Hero Smackdowns!
Top 5 Zombie Movies
Top 5 Gears of War Weapons
Top 5 Street Fighters
owlman166's Top 5 DC Wants
Top 5 HeroClix Accessories
Top 5 Superhero Movies
Top 6 Standard HeroClix Powers
Top 5 Worst Modern Age Sculpts
Top 5 Spider-Man Clix
5 Worst Modern Age Clix
Top 5 GsX Traits
Top 5 Movie-Clix
Top 5 Marvel Tech
Fixing Superman
5 Awesome Justice League Fights
5 Awesome Spider-Man Fights
Faces of Eddie
10 Battle Packs (We Want)
Marvel DUOS You Want
DC DUOS You Want!
Top 8 Sets We Want
22 HeroClix box sets (we want)
Top 10 Signs You're Obsessed with HeroClix
Top 5 Overrated Clix


Top 5 Hero vs Hero Smackdowns!
Eric Schaen (11/08/2011)
 Page:  1  2  3  4  5   

Related: Top 5 Street Fighters
Related: Top 5 Overrated HeroClix
Related: Top 20 in 2012
Related: owlman166's Top 5 DC Wants
Goto Comments

Top 5 Hero vs Hero SmackdownsLet’s face it, Superheroes are people too. Like any two individuals there are moments where circumstances or opposing views can lead to the occasional throw down.

Granted, Superheroes should be big enough to put aside their differences and work things out. However, we comic fans would miss out on some great moments if this were the case.

(not to mention, some superheroes truly deserve a good beating once in a while)

With that being said here are the Top 5 Hero vs Hero Smackdowns!

Justice League#5 Batman Vs. Guy Gardner
(Justice League #5)

When you have a jerk like Guy Gardner as part of your team, sooner or later there is bound to be some in team quarreling. Guy, being the jerk that he is, has been firing verbal shots at Batman since this new team’s inception.

In a moment of pure overconfidence mixed with testosterone, Guy challenges Batman to a fist fight. Claiming he doesn’t even need his power-ring to take down Bats, Guy removes his ring and gives it to a fellow Leaguer for safe keeping. Batman realizing that Guy needs a lesson in humility, taunts Guy into taking a swing. Guy cocks his fist back and Wham! Guy is out cold on the floor.

Moment’s later Black Canary enters the room and is upset, not that Guy has been knocked unconscious, but because she missed it. Blue Beetle is delirious with laughter and can only get two words out between laughs “One punch”.


 Page:  1  2  3  4  5   

Back to Top

Your Comments:
Marvel civil war should rank as number one easily. even if we're not counting team battles, the final showdown with iron man getting humbled by cap was just awesome.
i also agree with the ultimates cap vs giant man, that may have been the best story arc in the whole series

Posted by: Ste on 6/4/2012 10:30:39 AM
You missed one. Superman vs. Captain Marvel in Kindom Come. I'll take that over Wolverine / Spiderman any day.

Posted by: Another Guinness on 4/30/2012 1:37:41 AM
Batman vs. Superman is the best. 'Nuff said...

Posted by: Owlman166 on 3/16/2012 6:24:27 AM
I agree spider-man vs wolverine is cool but every one knows hulk vs thing is the best

Posted by: morgan smith on 12/30/2011 9:08:49 AM
NO WAY!!!!!! spidey vs wolverine is the best ever.

Posted by: theo on 11/27/2011 1:25:56 PM
Good list...And, to add one (now, Batman Is my fav character!!!) But THE throwdown between Batman and Karate Kid?? Bats throws one punch, then in two panels, KARATE KID kICKS BATMAN'S BUTT!!!! classic...almost, a NON fight...

Posted by: danny on 11/17/2011 12:27:44 PM
Superman vs. Hawk when it was revealed that Hawk was Monarch. The fight contained one of the few truly menacing lines ever uttered by the big S: "Please... don't make me hit you again."

Posted by: licensedhero on 11/16/2011 5:44:58 PM
A oldie but still a gud matchup. Hulk vs Wolverine. Of course the Hulk won, but regeneration helped wolverine make it a gud fight.

Posted by: Anthony Williams on 11/15/2011 9:40:41 AM
One of my favorites is from the Ultimates:

Captain America vs. Giant-Man. Cap finds out that Hank Pym put Janet in the hospital and then went AWOL. Cap goes off the grid himself and hunts Pym down as his 1940s sense of civility is offended. The beating he delivers to Pym is awesomely rendered, especially the shot where he climbs the stairs in a bar just so he can jump out the window at the height of Giant-Man's head.

The fight ends with tons of construction materials dropped on the head of the naked loser, and the line "How big do you feel now, dirtbag? How big do you feel now?"

The entire issue was an epic display of dark humor and jackbooted chivalry.

Posted by: Kragnorak on 11/14/2011 4:26:05 PM
one more to add, from way back in X-Men (during the old Phoenix saga) when the X-Men and Starjammers met. when encountering the guardian of the M'Kran Crystal wolverine figures he can take him easy (smaller runt than himself physically). Next Panel the Star Jammers Ship is reporting Wolverine hitting escape velocity from being hit so hard

Posted by: Grim on 11/10/2011 10:06:54 PM
Justice Leauge animated series: Superman vs. Captain Marvel... I could go on all day with this...

Posted by: Licensedhero on 11/10/2011 9:02:02 PM
I second Grim's offering, even though there was just that one punch, the pyschological blow-by-blow btw. Wayne & Jordan read as though it had the impact of a body blow to the reader. "So, you're back?"

Posted by: MEsch on 11/10/2011 12:01:45 PM
If multiple participants are allowed, I want to mention the Hulk vs. Iron Man, Wonder Man, Hercules and Namor somewhere around IH number 315 or so. John Byrne story. Excellent.

Posted by: licensedhero on 11/9/2011 7:10:31 PM
I like the JLA vs Avengers crossover for one reason. The fight between Thor and Superman. Granted Superman wins but then the rest of the Avengers beat the F*** out of him. It made me laugh seeing Superman getting beat up by other heavy hitters. Well worth the read

Posted by: Sir Christopher on 11/9/2011 3:19:57 PM
another one that should have been included was Spiderman Vs ilk when Hulk was changing at night (going by 'Mr. Fixit at the time IIRC) and Spiderman had the Cosmic Power.
One Punch and Hulk was Literaly in orbit.

Posted by: Grim on 11/9/2011 6:33:54 AM
I agree with some of the other comments about Thor/Superman fight needing to be here. #1 should have been the Batman punch to Guy's face. That book is still one of my all time favorite comics due to seeing it.

But you must not be old enough to remember the great battle way back in Daredevil #7 (1964)when DD battles Namor. DD fought him tooth and nail, never giving up until Namor stopped what he was doing and realized that He could never win against a hero like DD and then he left.

Posted by: Nightwing-fan on 11/9/2011 6:02:22 AM
well maybe it wasnt a total knockout, more of a knock down and Bats did not get up to gace him again, he waited to take him unawares in teh Batcave for a cheap shot, but still qualifies more than most of this list. most are just good fights/scraps. only the Batman/Guy Gardner one was a true Smackdown IMHO. (Qualifier being a humiliating defeat)

Posted by: Grim on 11/8/2011 10:17:53 PM
To be fair, Jordan didn't KO Batman, he only knocked him down... Mad props to the author of this for the number one selection from a barely comic. I haven't read it in years, but I loved the part where Spidey knocks Wolverine up in the air, who comes strait back down, claws first. Spiderman's dodge is classic

Posted by: Licensedhero on 11/8/2011 8:54:11 PM
how can you not include Hal Jordan knocking out Batman with one punch in Green lantern Rebirth? Come on, Bats was acting like the Jerk Guy Gardner usually is and Hals Ring wasnt even Lit when he hit Bats. and all after John Stewart chewing out Batman for the real reason he doesnt like Jordan, Jordan is not afraid of Bats (and if you dont fear him Bat Man is just a man)plus the Looks on Guy's and Kilowog's faces made it even better

Posted by: Grim on 11/8/2011 6:55:34 PM
Superman vs. Thor is absolutely a must if this list got expanded... Also noteworthy would be Hal Jordan vs. Batman in Green Lantern: Rebirth. if only for the look on Guy Gardner's face. Also if this list got expanded, my choice for the best non-big 2 hero vs. hero: Dragon vs. Super Patriot in Thee Savage Dragon (min-series) #2

Posted by: Licensedhero on 11/8/2011 6:30:47 PM
Anybody with access to it, take a look at Iron Man vs. Sub-Mariner from Tales to Astonish #81...a visually breathtaking battle sequence, courtesy of the master himself, Jack Kirby.
And kudos to the author for including FF #112...I remember reading it back when it first came out, and the impact of the story has always stuck with me.

Posted by: dirkzorn on 11/8/2011 8:54:54 AM
I know it says Super Hero vs Super Hero but one battle that always sticks out in my head is Avengers vs JLA. Issue 3 when Thor n Superman battle it out and Supes finally knocks out Thor. This gives the Avengers pause before Iron Man, who's always had a hard time wrapping his around Thor's Asgardian roots, throwing the first blow on Supes. The rest of the Avengers heavy hitters commencing a brutal beatdown on the Man of Steel stating, "you don't ever do that to him!" To me, it shows how the Avengers are considered family whereas the JLA are more of friends. Still gives me goosebumps to this day when I think about it.

Posted by: geminimerc on 11/8/2011 7:45:22 AM